Bynum's Steakhouse: A Flavorful Meat and Seafood Destination

We love Bynums, but since we live out of town, we don't go very often. This time, everything was just as wonderful as we had always remembered. It's hard to believe that the best shrimp cocktail we've ever had is at this restaurant in Martinsville, Indiana. My wife had a steak, and I had the prime rib, and both were excellent. They make a very nice martini, as well. We will definitely have to go more often.

The restaurant is so cool, like a museum with artifacts John has collected over the years. I had Sirloin tips and they were cooked to perfection, so much and delicious. I got a baked potato that was hot and soft just like I like it. Tina is awesome.

Overall the experience was good. Clean and friendly atmosphere. Staff is very attentive and kind. The food was good, some items are overly priced while other items are a bit more affordable. I've included two pictures of the entire menu. Personally it was my first time visiting this establishment so I was very excited, but then a little disappointed in the menu options. There is no picking or choosing sides, you get what they give you which is a basket of bread with butter, a bowl of basic sald and a bowl of beef onion soup which is their version of french onion soup but it basically noting but broth with some shredded cheese at the bottom of the bowl, there were two slivers of onion in my broth and it wasn't warm enough to melt the cheese. I personally ordered the pork chops which were beautiful (all the meat looked fantastic) and it did taste good however it was quite dry, not as tender and juicy as it looked like it would have been. I can't speak for the other dishes (party of 14) but everyone seemed to be satisfied. So if you're looking for a nice place to eat and you're in the area I'd recommend giving this establishment a GO at least once. And I must add that our waitresses was really great which is why I'm giving 5 Stars.

I haven’t been here since I was in the single digits, I forgot how great it was here! We went here for my mom’s 64th birthday with my aunt and uncle. My mom got a burger, aunt got a pork chop, uncle got beef tips and I got the surf n turf. ( 12oz sirloin and shrimp) The layout of this place is different, very cool but different, kinda gives you a feeling of being underground or in a cave, it’s very cool. And the French onion soup is INCREDIBLE!!!

Food great. Very disappointed in fact that our server did not acknowledge that it was my moms birthday. And I even told them about mine being day before which we were out celebrating. I have never been to place doesn't give you a desert for a birthday. So we decided after go get are on desert. But we had party of 5. So the other 3 were going to buy a desert. Which would made her tip bigger since we spent more. Ig that's what happens when you don't acknowledge a birthday. Great steak. I have just been to alot of great steak houses for my birthday. And I have never had them not give me a desert. Not all classy places sing. I understand that but no desert. It really would made way bigger tip.

Truly 5 star experience. Friendly staff, and it felt like a fancy multi-course meal. The sword fish was fantastic, the steak was a great cut and cooked perfectly. This is my new go to steak house.

Great place to have a steak. It is tucked away just off I 69. The staff were all very good and the steaks were cooked perfect to order. Everything was reasonably priced. The restaurant was clean. Each entree came with three sides that inckuded a salad and their soup of the day. Bread is brought out early and was very good.

Its been years. All I remember is the menu was limited. Steak and a few other options. The steak was great. It was the first time id ever had French onion soup. It was pretty darn good. The decor was weird and there is a weird little museum in the back of the building. Would stop in again if im ever in that part of Indiana again.